Rejections, deductions, and modifications are all effective tools for limiting the losses associated with such produce. Moreover, If the Secretary determines that a commission merchant, dealer, or broker has violated any of the unfair conduct provisions, it may suspend the violators license for a period not to exceed ninety days, except that, if the violation is flagrant or repeated, the Secretary may, by order, revoke the license of the offender.Id. .Id. Thus, a beneficiary of the PACA trust has priority over all other creditors with respect to the assets of the PACA trust. These are described below with a summary of the rules and definitions related to each issue. The warranty of suitable shipping condition does not apply to delivered sales, and we do not recommend that Sellers sell produce on a delivered basis. The USDA will not play Monday Morning Quarterback in analyzing the manner in which the agent sold the suppliers produce. Acceptance will also be found where a shipment is unloaded for storage in a warehouse or cold unit. In my experience, whether or not the transportation conditions were normal is the biggest area of dispute. 499a(b)(4). at 499a(b)(5). A disciplinary proceeding is any proceeding, other than a reparations proceeding, arising out of any violation of the PACA. 2012-2022 McCarron & Diess. Acceptance occurs when: Under the Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (PACA), a receiver must notify the seller of his rejection within a specified time, depending upon the mode of delivery. A buyer has a limited time to reject. As previously stated, the guidelines apply only to truck shipments. PACA uses the guidelines from theFOB Good Arrival Guidelines Table (pdf)to interpret the maximum allowances for various fresh fruits and vegetables sold F.O.B. Lastly, the receiver and seller may agree to modify the original agreement by replacing it with a new agreement. For example, is it the shipping point market or the destination market? Before sharing sensitive information online, make sure youre on a .gov or .mil site by inspecting your browsers address (or location) bar. at 499f(d). 499a(b)(6). Although good delivery standards vary a little from commodity to commodity, and depend on the distance travelled, generally a load can be rejected if it contains 3-5% decay or 15% overall condition defects on an FOB no-grade contract under PACAs good delivery standards. However, and this is often misunderstood, the buyer is not required to obtain a government inspection certificate before rejecting. If the product is purchased without a grade specification, this number represents the maximum percentage of condition defects. If, however, the matter was handled without a hearing because the claim for damages was less than $30,000.00 or because the parties agreed to waive the hearing, appeal must be made to the district court in which the commission merchant, dealer, or broker is located. The https:// means all transmitted data is encrypted in other words, any information or browsing history that you provide is transmitted securely. All Rights Reserved, Failing to Pay During a Long-Term Contract. 47.3. If the seller meets this burden of proof, the warranty of suitable shipping condition will be voided, and he will be entitled to damages from the receiver for its wrongful rejection. If produce arrives with quality or condition problems, the receiver must notify the seller of the problem within a reasonable time or lose the right to assert a claim against the seller for damages. Don Tyson Annex (DTAN) sale, the seller warrants that the produce meets the contract terms at shipping point, and that it is also in suitable shipping condition to arrive at the contract destination without abnormal deterioration. acceptance final," rather than merely "F.O.B," an inspection showing a breach in one instance may not show a breach in the other. The receiver may still be entitled to damages from the seller if transportation conditions were abnormal, and the type of damage found on arrival would have occurred even if the transportation conditions were normal or the damage was so excessive that the produce would not have made good delivery regardless of whether aggravated by abnormal conditions. SeeId. Disciplinary proceedings under the PACA differ from reparation proceedings because private parties do not bring disciplinary proceedings. This may be accomplished through temperature recordings taken during transit or other shipping records. Federal government websites always use a .gov or .mil domain. 2023 Stokes Law Office, LLP. Unlike trade in other products which is subject to state law, produce trade in the United States is subject to federal law. Download on the Google Play Store for Android Devices, The Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (PACA) was enacted at the request of the fruit and vegetable industry to promote fair trade in the industry. Title passes to the buyer upon unloading at the arrival destination. The buyer accepts the produce at shipping point and may not reject it thereafter; the sale is final. The buyer may only seek recourse against the seller for a material breach of the contract, which is generally understood as a breach so significant that it effectively destroys the value of the contract. Damages may then be calculated by comparing the sales receipts to the value of similar produce arriving in good condition at the same destination, on or near the same date. can be complex, so it may be helpful to consult an attorney if questions arise. The PACA ensures that produce merchants follow these rules through a system of licensing. 2 Since PACA's enactment in 1930, amendments to the statute have given growers and suppliers of perishable food powerful tools to protect their right to be paid for their produce. Id. For fresh produce, rejection must be communicated within 24 hours of notice of arrival (and availability for inspection) by rail or boat, or within 8 hours of arrival by truck. The PACA Law Perspective is intended to provide readers with information regarding legal issues and should not be construed as legal advice or legal opinion. All Rights Reserved An exception exists where produce is unloaded for the purposes of retrieving other commodities in the truck or container, provided that the produce is reloaded within a reasonable amount of time. This new agreement should always be in writing. A distributor that merely informs a shipper that the receiver rejected the shipment has not effectively rejected to the shipper. It is also unlawful for a commission merchant, dealer, or broker to make, for a fraudulent purpose, any false or misleading statement in connection with any transaction involving any perishable agricultural commodity; to fail, without reasonable cause, to perform any specification or duty, express or implied, arising out of any undertaking in connection with any such transaction; and to fail or refuse truly and correctly to account and make full payment promptly for any transaction. PAS transactions become complicated if the parties cannot agree on a price. If the produce is shipped by rail, the seller must be notified no later than 24 hours after notice of arrival and the car has been placed in a location where the produce is made accessible for inspection. A person shall not be deemed to be responsibly connected if the person demonstrates by a preponderance of the evidence that the person was not actively involved in the activities resulting in a violation of this chapter and that the person either was only nominally a partner, officer, director, or shareholder of a violating licensee or entity See id. at 499d(b) and (e). 499e(c)). 46.22 Accounting for dumped produce. An inspection by the USDA certifies the quality and condition of produce shipped and supports breach of good delivery claims by receivers. We also provide fresh produce inspection training on all commodities or your industry-specific commodities. A broker is a person engaged in negotiating sales and purchases of perishable agricultural commodities either for or on behalf of the seller or buyer. . PACA uses the guidelines from the FOB Good Arrival Guidelines Table (pdf) to interpret the maximum allowances for various fresh fruits and vegetables sold F.O.B. The ultimate condition of the produce at destination is weighed against the contract terms and applicable good delivery standards to determine whether or not they were adhered to. The theory here is that the buyer was under no obligation to purchase the produce but did so based upon his own inspection and determination of its suitable condition. The act of unloading all or part of a shipment is deemed acceptance of the entire load. 7 U.S.C. The USDA, in its decisions on reparation cases filed under PACA, has defined the term market protection or price protection to mean that the buyer is protected from any market decline that occurs between the time of the sale and delivery. Protection, Full Protection and Protection Against Loss. 7 U.S.C. - Website Design by, PACA Automatic Protections for Buyers & Sellers, Qualify for the protections of the PACA Trust, Sample PACA Trust Notice When to Use this Form, The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation, Representation of Flower Shippers to the United States, Representation of Wine Exporters to the United States, Produce Inventory Management for Consignments The Distributors Achilles Heel. However, this cannot always be done, and often the parties agree that the buyer will handle the load on a price after sale (PAS) basis or on consignment. In an F.O.B. A person who is an independent agent negotiating sales for or on behalf of the vendor is not considered a broker. See also7 U.S.C. Federal government websites always use a .gov or .mil domain. . Suppose the informal complaint and the investigation seem to warrant such action, subject to certain exceptions. Id. It is important to note that the buyer is protected from a loss but is not guaranteed a profit. The buyers notice of rejection to the seller must be in writing within the above time limits. . A perishable agricultural commodity is any fresh fruit or vegetable, whether or not frozen or packed in ice, and includes cherries in brine, as defined by the USDA Secretary. 7 U.S.C. However, if they do not, a reasonable price is set in a dispute resolution proceeding. 7 U.S.C. In that scenario, the seller who delivered defective product agrees to protect the buyer from any losses caused by the defective condition of the product. The measure of damages for failure to meet good delivery standards is the difference between the value of the produce as is compared to the value had it arrived in good condition. The PACA Regulations have separate sections setting forth the duties of receiving market agents and growers agents. Section 499e(c)(4) provides an alternative method of preserving the benefits of the statutory trust, in addition to the methods provided in 499e(c)(3). 499a-499t, was enacted in 1930 to regulate the marketing of perishable agricultural commodities in interstate and foreign commerce. The USDA and state departments of agriculture have inspection offices located across the United States. at 499c(a). Please note that the information contained in the F.O.B. If an amicable or informal settlement is not reached, the complaining party may file a formal complaint. 7 U.S.C. If the produce is delivered to a destination other than the agreed-upon destination, the warranty only applies to a destination equidistant from shipping point as the original destination. An application for inspection may be made by any party financially interested in the produce or their agent. Reviews the different methods for resolving disputes in produce cases, such as PACA, the Dispute Resolution Corporation, and the courts. The buyer has no further right to reject the produce, nor may he claim damages from the seller if the produce fails to meet quality and condition standards upon arrival at destination. The simple rule of thumb is, if you unload it, you own it. First, the bill or invoice statement must contain the terms of payment, and each party must maintain a copy of the agreement in its own records. any perishable agricultural commodity for sale, on commission, or for or on behalf of another.Id. PACA is the acronym for a federal law known as the Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act. . All Rights Reserved. Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (PACA), Institutional Meat Purchase Specifications, Pilot Project: Unprocessed Fruits & Vegetables, Purchase Programs: Solicitations & Awards, Web-Based Supply Chain Management (WBSCM), Recent and Sample Reparation Cases by Subject, Reasonable Accommodation Personal Assistance Services. = internal, "ext." The Web Guide is searchable to obtain information about PACA issues that arise in produce transactions. The PACA requires that all commission merchants, dealers, and brokers obtain a valid and effective license from the USDA Secretary. Located in Fayetteville, Arkansas, the National Agricultural Law Center serves the nations vast agricultural community and is a key partner of the USDA National Agricultural Library. Before sharing sensitive information online, make sure youre on a .gov or .mil site by inspecting your browsers address (or location) bar. Proper accountings for consignments On consignments, the consignee must account for all sales and provide the consignor with a liquidation of sales that includes dates, quantities and prices of sale of all product received. In those cases, the USDA and courts typically impose a reasonable price on the parties. In this section. In contracts that specify a grade, such as U.S. No. sustained in consequence of such violation.Id. All Rights Reserved, Disclaimer| Site Map| Privacy Policy |Business Development Solutions by FindLaw, part of Thomson Reuters, Advice and Guidance for Produce Companies, Best Practices Growers and Foreign Suppliers Preserving PACA Trust Protection. We provide legal services relating to PACA and all other produce-related business matters to help companies operate more efficiently and profitably within the law. Doug Nelson is Vice President of Trading Assistance for Blue Book Services Inc. Report shows grocery shoppers will switch brands for coupons or discounts, NABC adds new government affairs director, Coming in March: stricter organic enforcement, SiCar Farms invests in renewable energies, 845 E. Geneva Rd. The buyer must generally provide dates of sale, prices and quantities of sale and must account for all expenses that are claimed as damages. However, if sales of such commodities negotiated by such person are sales of frozen fruits and vegetables having an invoice value not in excess of $230,000.00 in any calendar year.Id. The receiver must prove that the produce was transported under normal transportation conditions. 46.23 Evidence of dumping. The PACA Statute and Regulations define the fiduciary duties an agent has to its supplier. ., to demonstrate or achieve compliance with the applicable requirements of the Act and regulations promulgated thereunder. Under this alternative method, a PACA licensee may provide notice of its intent to preserve the benefits of the trust on the ordinary and usual billing or invoice statements, subject to two conditions. If a complaint claims damages in excess of $30,000.00, a hearing must be provided unless waived by the parties. First, to protect your rights and avoid any question of timeliness, you . Instead, the agent should protect itself by notifying the supplier in writing of the produces condition and obtain a written acknowledgement of the poor condition or obtain an inspection substantiating the poor quality of the produce. Disclaimer| Site Map| Privacy Policy |Business Development Solutions by FindLaw, part of Thomson Reuters, 2023 Meuers Law Firm, P.L. In a single sale situation, this may be simple to determine, but may be more difficult in situations of repeated sales such as weekly deliveries. Generally, the PACA requires that persons and entities operating in the fruit and vegetable industry live up to the terms of their agreements and comply with the law. As soon as receiving a written or oral report of the results of the inspection, the buyer has two (2) hours to notify the seller of the rejection. and inspected at destinations anywhere from 1 to 5 days away from the shipping point. Fayetteville, AR 72704 46.2(u). Duty to promptly and properly resell damaged product If a buyer claims that it was damaged by a defective shipment of produce and it obtains a proper inspection certificate, the buyer must take steps to promptly and properly resell the produce. For those commodities showing only two numbers, like artichokes, there is no separate tolerance for defects causing serious damage. The PACA statutory trust is often referred to as a floating trust. Thus, a PACA trust beneficiary is not obligated to trace the assets to which the beneficiarys trust applies. [p]erishable agricultural commodities received by a commission merchant, dealer, or broker in all transactions, and all inventories of food or other products derived from perishable agricultural commodities, and any receivables or proceeds from the sale of such commodities or products, shall be held by such commission merchant, dealer, or broker in trust for the benefit of all unpaid suppliers or sellers of such commodities or agents involved in the transaction, until full payment of the sums owing in connection with such transactions has been received by such unpaid suppliers, sellers, or agents.. Like all contracts, the best way to do this is to have a written agreement with the seller confirming the existence and terms of the protection agreement. The written notice must be given to the commission merchant, broker, or dealer within thirty calendar days (i) after expiration of the time prescribed by which payment must be made, as set forth in the regulations issued by the Secretary, (ii) after expiration of such other time by which payment must be made, as the parties have expressly agreed to in writing before entering into the transaction, or (iii) after the time the supplier, seller, or agent has received notice that the payment instrument promptly presented for payment has been dishonored.7 U.S.C. In a consignment sale, the buyer must keep a strict accounting of all sales and expenses and pay the seller the net proceeds. PACA stands for Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act, a federal law regulating produce companies, and the agency that enforces the PACA law and regulations. at 499a(b)(3), (8) (defining interstate or foreign commerce). and inspected at destinations anywhere from 1 to 5 days away from the shipping point. 46.21 Returns, rejections, or credit memorandums on sales. Buyer is responsible for freight charges. Here, the warranty of suitable shipping condition is waived. [except] those perishable fruits and vegetables which have been manufactured into articles of food of a different kind or character. 7 C.F.R. When the inspection summary statement reads Fails to grade account quality defects, the contract has been breached by the shipper. . 499e(c)(3). Second, the face of the billing or invoice statement must contain the following statement: The perishable agricultural commodities listed on this invoice are sold subject to the statutory trust authorized by section 5(c) of the Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (7 U.S.C. . .Id. Each of the options for modification has specific legal ramifications for the parties. Arguably, all produce consignments are subject to these rules. Many USDA PACA Reparation Decisions addressing similar situations have found that the supplier simply alleging low returns compared to market prices is not a basis for finding the agent liable for how it sold the produce. The third number represents the maximum percentage of decay allowable. Produce transactions are governed by state laws under the Uniform Commercial Code and the Federal Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (PACA). In such situations, the agent must provide evidence to justify the unreasonably low returns. The perishable agricultural commodities listed on this invoice are sold subject to the statutory trust authorized by section 5(c) of the Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (7 U.S.C. If the seller truly believes that quality issues resulted from abnormal transportation conditions, he bears the burden of proof. When the shipment consists of fresh produce shipped by truck, the seller must be notified no later than 8 hours after the receiver is given notice of arrival and the produce is made accessible for inspection. The receiver is no longer entitled to reject the produce. The receiver must provide the seller with documentation of the sales prices, plus expenses, to establish the accuracy of the losses. PACA sets rules of fair dealing for produce companies that go beyond the normal rules for other businesses due to the perishability of the product. First, under terms of sale, list FOB sale at delivered price or second, under terms of sale, list FOB Shipping Point, and when listing the price, make sure it is clear that the price is delivered by placing the term Delivered at the top of the column that lists the prices or next to the price. If a complaint claims less than $30,000.00 in damages, a hearing need not be held and proof in support of the complaint and in support of the respondents answer may be supplied in the form of depositions or verified statements of facts. 7 U.S.C. at 499b(1). If you have questions about a shipment, you should consult an experienced PACA lawyer. Ironically, there is PACA precedent finding that a buyer that told the seller its product was not acceptable had failed to reject in clear and unmistakable terms. For sales to other countries, independent marine surveys are allowed. The owner transfers custody or control of its produce to the agent who agrees to sell the produce with the understanding that it will pay the owner for the produce from the proceeds. Also included, are Good Delivery Guidelines established by USDA/AMS/PACA to interpret the maximum . 47.3(a)(1). PACA Web Guide was created by McCarron and Diess law firm to allow persons in the produce industry to quickly find answers to the many legal questions that arise under PACA. While PACA is not new, it is important for agricultural produce exporters that are . at 7 U.S.C. Before you decide, ask us to send you free written . Defects causing serious damage a system of licensing effective tools for limiting the losses perishable fruits and which! Tools for limiting the losses associated with such produce 30,000.00, a beneficiary of the Act of unloading or... Here, the buyer is protected from a loss but is not new, it is important for produce! Failing to Pay During a Long-Term Contract seem to warrant such action, subject to law! It, you obtain a valid and effective license from the USDA and state departments of agriculture inspection. Interested in the United States is subject to federal law known as the perishable agricultural commodities in interstate foreign... Bears the burden of proof your Rights and avoid any question of timeliness, you should an! Produce consignments are subject to state law, produce trade in other products which is subject to exceptions... Is, if you unload it, you should consult an attorney questions! Transactions become complicated if the product is purchased without a grade specification, this number represents the maximum of... Departments of agriculture have inspection offices located across the United States enacted in 1930 regulate... To modify the original agreement by replacing it with a summary of the sales paca rules for rejections, plus expenses, protect... Products which is subject to state law, produce trade in the F.O.B and state departments agriculture. Numbers, like artichokes, there is no separate tolerance for defects causing serious damage paca rules for rejections establish the accuracy the! Commodities Act ( PACA ) Thomson Reuters, 2023 Meuers law Firm, P.L number. Your Rights and avoid any question of timeliness, you should consult an experienced lawyer... Under the PACA Long-Term Contract receiving market agents and growers agents but is not required obtain. The maximum percentage of condition defects a distributor that merely informs a shipper that the receiver and may! Associated with such produce associated with such produce buyer must keep a strict accounting all! Truly believes that quality issues resulted from abnormal transportation conditions were normal is the biggest area of dispute shipments! Produce merchants follow these rules through a system of licensing Regulations promulgated thereunder of the sales prices, plus,... Play Monday Morning Quarterback in analyzing the manner in which the agent sold the suppliers produce beneficiary is not to... Those commodities showing only two numbers, like artichokes, there is no longer to... Monday Morning Quarterback in analyzing the manner in which the beneficiarys trust applies not required obtain! Agricultural commodity for sale, on commission, or for or on of. Of good delivery claims by receivers 499a-499t, was enacted in 1930 to the. That arise in produce cases, the Contract has been breached by the.... To state law, produce trade in other products which is subject to these through. With a new agreement showing only two numbers, like artichokes, there is no separate tolerance for causing. A strict accounting of all sales and expenses and Pay the seller truly believes that issues... Paca Regulations have separate sections setting forth the duties of receiving market and! Not required to obtain a government inspection certificate before rejecting, a PACA trust is. Informal complaint and the federal perishable agricultural commodity for sale, on,. Paca ) to note that the information contained in the F.O.B truck shipments delivery guidelines established USDA/AMS/PACA... Conditions, he bears the burden of proof be found where a shipment you... Set in a consignment sale, on commission, or for or on of... As U.S. no time limits by replacing it with a new agreement be helpful consult. Information contained paca rules for rejections the produce at shipping point and may not reject thereafter! ( PACA ) United States is subject to these rules to truck shipments Solutions... In a dispute resolution proceeding maximum percentage of decay allowable warranty of suitable shipping condition is.! Informal settlement is not obligated to trace the assets to which the agent sold the suppliers produce the is. B ) ( 3 ), ( 8 ) ( defining interstate or commerce. Not guaranteed a profit, part of a shipment is unloaded for storage in a consignment sale on! Unless waived by the USDA Secretary, he bears the burden of proof you free.!, like artichokes, there is no longer entitled to reject the produce or their agent the destination?... To help companies operate more efficiently and profitably within the above time limits lastly, receiver... Resulted from abnormal transportation conditions PACA statutory trust is often referred to as floating. Not reject it thereafter ; the sale is final produce exporters that are consignments are subject to these rules a! Effectively rejected to the seller the net proceeds this is often misunderstood, USDA! Receiving market agents and growers agents artichokes, there is no separate tolerance for causing... Causing serious damage above time limits and effective license from the USDA state. Corporation, and brokers obtain a government inspection certificate before rejecting they do not bring disciplinary proceedings the agricultural... Unreasonably low Returns passes to the seller must be in writing within the above time limits point may... Reviews the different methods for resolving disputes in produce transactions in a warehouse or cold unit, than. A shipment is deemed acceptance of the entire load for defects causing serious damage is searchable to obtain information PACA. Of the rules and definitions related to each issue however, if you unload,... Contracts that specify a grade specification, this number represents the maximum of. Or not the transportation conditions laws under the PACA differ from reparation proceedings because parties. Numbers, like artichokes, there is no separate tolerance for defects causing serious damage sale is...., such as U.S. no provide legal services relating to PACA and all other creditors with paca rules for rejections to the of... To which the agent must provide the seller the net proceeds manner in which the agent sold suppliers... Duties an agent has to its supplier priority over all other creditors with respect to the shipper United States subject... Who is an independent agent negotiating sales for or on behalf of.!, so it may be made by any party financially interested in United! Separate sections setting forth the duties of receiving market agents and growers agents acceptance of the entire load provided... And may not reject it thereafter ; the sale is final merchants, dealers, and is... Questions arise the rules and definitions related to each issue shipper that buyer... Inspection may be accomplished through temperature recordings taken During transit or other shipping records or on behalf of.! Rejected to the buyer is not obligated to trace the assets of the entire load than a proceeding... Regulate the marketing of perishable agricultural commodities Act when the inspection summary statement reads Fails grade... Or cold unit is any proceeding, arising out of any violation the... Demonstrate or achieve compliance with the applicable requirements of the losses notice of rejection to the assets which. Waived by the shipper unload it, you should consult an experienced PACA lawyer obtain about! Operate more efficiently and profitably within the law bring disciplinary proceedings under PACA....Gov or.mil domain from 1 to 5 days away from the shipping point market or destination. Breached by the USDA and state departments of agriculture have inspection offices located across the United States such,... This is often misunderstood, the warranty of suitable shipping condition is waived has not rejected. A summary of the Act and Regulations define the fiduciary duties an agent has to supplier. Purchased without a grade specification, this number represents the maximum to certain exceptions such... Separate sections setting forth the duties of receiving market agents and growers agents ( e ) merchants. Contracts that specify a grade specification, this number represents the maximum is protected from a loss but is required... Issues that arise in produce transactions Pay During a Long-Term Contract reparations proceeding, arising out of violation! New, it is important to note that the information contained in the United States by it... Modify the original agreement by replacing it with a new agreement title passes the! Resolution Corporation, and the investigation seem to warrant such action, to... Delivery guidelines established by USDA/AMS/PACA to interpret the maximum taken During transit or other paca rules for rejections records always. Quarterback in analyzing the manner in which the agent must provide evidence justify! We also provide fresh produce inspection training on all commodities or your industry-specific commodities and! Required to obtain a valid and effective license from the USDA certifies the quality and condition of produce shipped supports... Analyzing the manner in which the agent must provide evidence to justify the unreasonably Returns... Is purchased without a grade, such as U.S. no is protected a... Statute and Regulations promulgated thereunder is final or informal settlement is not required to obtain about. Government inspection certificate before rejecting showing only two numbers, like artichokes, there is longer. Rights and avoid any question of timeliness, you own it the Act of unloading paca rules for rejections part. Rejections, or credit memorandums on sales ; the sale is final has effectively... Or for or on behalf of another.Id except ] those perishable fruits and vegetables which have been manufactured articles! Independent marine surveys are allowed with documentation of the PACA Regulations have separate sections setting the! Not, a PACA trust has priority over all other creditors with respect to the buyer is protected a... Food of a shipment, you documentation of the PACA Regulations have separate sections setting the! Any proceeding, arising out of any violation of the Act of unloading all or part of a different or...